Saturday, August 15, 2009

Port Call

The past two days we made our scheduled port call in Málaga, Spain for supplies and to transfer several of the scientific crew. Those on the first leg of the project were glad to stretch their legs ashore for a short time in between the bustle of debriefing those arriving to ensure consistency in protocols and data collection. It was a festive time in the city; our brief time there happened to coincide with the beginning of Feria de Málaga which is celebrated for nine days beginning on the Friday of the second half of August in honor of the merging of Málaga to the Castilian Crown due to the conquest by the Catholic Monarchs in 1487. This made for some minor challenges in getting people and gear to the port with the crowds, but all went according to schedule and we are now steaming back out to sea. The picture here shows our departure from this Spanish port city under a pleasant sunset.

Tonight we had an all-hands meeting to discuss plans for the second leg and review the protocols with everyone as a group. We have a good deal of consistency between the two legs, but do have some changes in personnel in key roles. Thus we wanted to make sure we were all on the same page with the many specific protocols for safety and data collection for our different operational modes. Additionally, we will conduct several practice drills tomorrow deploying gear and personnel in a mock run of a tagging and controlled exposure exercise. The sound source will be deployed for practice and timing, but not turned on during this drill. After this drill, we will switch to survey mode and begin searching for animals. The weather forecast is for marginal conditions, but improving over the next several days.

Thursday, August 13, 2009

Tantalizing

The forecast last night was for winds around 12 knots this morning, but it dawned very calm. The whales we stopped working with at 9 last night were near a main concentration of beaked whales seen last year. To get the best odds of being with whales this morning, we conducted an acoustic survey of much of last year's concentration from midnight to 0700 when there starts being enough light for the visual team to work. Unfortunately, there were so many dolphins that it was difficult to search for the subtle clicks of beaked whales among the cacaphony of sound that dolphins make in the Med when they are feeding at night. In fact, one of the sounds is called nacchere in Italian. This is the word for castanets. When striped dolphins are around at night, there is often a constant background of these sounds.

Because it was so hard to detect beaked whales acoustically last night, we positioned the ship where we last were with whales at 9 the night before. The dolphins were still active acoustically, but the observation conditions were excellent for the visual observers. As the morning went on, the sounds of the dolphins became quieter, making it possible to search for beaked whale clicks acoustically as well.

Just before 11 AM the visual observers sighted beaked whales, and as before, several groups were sighted relatively quickly in the same general area. As before on this cruise, there seem to be clusters of groups of animals. The observers first settled on a group of 4 adult whales, 2 males (which can easily be identified by the white coloration of the front of their bodies), and 2 females.

The tag boat was deployed just before 1140. The best opportunity to tag this group came when the tag boat was within about 100 m of a surfacing, the perfect distance, but as the tag boat moved over, a group of dolphins swam over to the beaked whales and swam around them. Apparently, they were bothering the whales, as one of the beaked whale breached right among them. After the dolphin incident, the behavior of the whales changed. They changed their direction of travel and this prevented the tag boat from completing its approach.

At 1343, the visual observers switched to follow a group with two females and one male that was with a dorsal fin that was curled over to the side. This marking made it easier to make sure we were on the same group. In addition, this group seemed to keep surfacing in pretty much the same area, making it easier to position the tag boat.
After the observers switched to the group of three, the white male surfaced and blew normally, and then swam for about ten minutes just several meters below the sea surface. It was quite easy from the ship to observe the white shape of the male continuously, and the visual observers directed the tag boat close enough that they were able to follow him underwater even from their lower vantage point. They tailed long behind him until he and the females surfaced. Even though they were quite close, the beaked whales were travelling, and at this speed it was hard for the small tag boat to close on them for tagging.

In the end we were able to follow the same group of 3 beaked whales from surfacing to surfacing over a period of 5 hours. This leads to what probably are the craziest tracks that the Alliance has ever made. It is a tribute to the bridge officers that they are able to position such a large ship so well for following whales. The ability to make these kinds of observations is remarkable for a species that is so cryptic that new species of these large mammals are regularly discovered each decade. The coordination with the tag boat was excellent, and they had several good opportunities for tagging, but in the end we just were not able to close to a few meters distance for tagging. This is the reality with tagging beaked whales. There are a series of steps, each of which takes time, skill, and the appropriate equipment. It just takes a reasonable number of attempts even in the best of conditions to succeed in getting all steps done in time.

This was the last day of tagging effort before a partial change of crew tomorrow. We had to stop an hour before sunset and recover the tag boat. The entire team had a barbecue out in the middle of the study area as the sun went down before we head into port.

Everyone who is leaving wishes the second phase of the cruise fair seas and best of luck with tagging.

Wednesday, August 12, 2009

the mystery clicks

Today dawned calmer than predicted. In our efforts to find workable seas over the past few days, we have moved out of the area surveyed for whales last year. This morning we started heading back to the hot spots in the areas surveyed last year and during the earlier parts of this cruise, listening and watching for whales, with a course that we hoped would cover favorable habitat for beaked whales. Many who study the distribution of beaked whales have noticed that not only do beaked whales favor areas where the bottom is 1000m deep, they also seem to congregate in submarine canyons or seamounts. Our course took us in deep water past several sea mounts. In the early afternoon, the acoustic monitors started picking up faint clicks like those of beaked whales in the direction of the seamount where beaked whales had been detected on a survey track last year. When they noticed that there appeared to be several whales clicking at the same time, we diverted the ship to the area, pulled up the hydrophones for maneuverability, and maneuvered the ship for optimal sighting of where the clicks were detected. The sighting conditions were excellent, yet the observers did not sight any beaked whales at all. Beaked whales can dive for more than an hour, but in a concentration, some whales should certainly have surfaced at that time. In deciding whether to continue to wait or to move on, we noticed that our depth was shallower than optimal for beaked whales. We therefore decided to move directly into deeper water where concentrations of whales were sighted last year. As we reached this area, around 6:30 PM, the visual observers sighted several groups of beaked whales and the acoustic team heard clicks from at least one foraging dive. We approached toward the groups, recovered the hydrophone arrays for maneuverability, and once we got close, we deployed the tagging boat. For some reason on this cruise, the tag boat keeps getting deployed late in the day even though we start at sunrise! The visual team noticed calves in several of the groups and was able to position the tag boat near surfacings of a group that did not have a calf in it. However, we were not able to get the tag boat close enough to attempt to tag before the whales appear to have made a deep foraging dive. The daylight did not hold out for us to be able to follow the whales and attempt tagging later.

Today’s efforts reinforce again how difficult it is to tag a beaked whale. You have to find animals, select a promising group, get an idea of their behavior and movement patterns and get a small boat within a few hundred meters of a group of whales coming up from a 15+ minute dive, when the whales could move more than a few hundred meters.

Tuesday, August 11, 2009

Not so much wind, but waves remain


After the winds of yesterday, it was a relief today to have winds mostly around 10 knots or less. But swells and waves remained from yesterday, creating difficulties for the visual observers. The acoustic monitoring worked well, and we set a course outside of our normal survey tracks in order to get the best weather conditions we could find for beaked whales. Twice during the day, acoustics got good enough detections to direct the ship nearby the whales, get a bearing, and orient the ship for optimal location for the visual observers to monitor the location where the whales were heard. Both times the visual observers were able to sight whales even though the visibility conditions were marginal. Unfortunately, the conditions were too rough to attempt tagging. We considered using a large workboat from the ship for tagging, but even then the conditions were not good enough.

The tag team kept itself busy analyzing data from one of the tagged pilot whales from earlier in the cruise. The dive profile shows that this whale spent most of its time near the surface in the top 15 m, but it did make one deep dive to nearly 650 m that lasted 11 min. Even though we had great observation conditions of the pilot whales, none of the visual observers had any idea that the whale had made this dive. The whale made echolocation clicks starting at the red asterisk and ending at the green asterisk. The black asterisks in between mark times that the whale accelerated the clicks, which we think means that she had identified a prey item she wanted, and she attempted to capture it. The recordings from the surface also include lots of social calling. All in all, a fascinating glimpse into a few hours in the life of these whales.

» Listen to Pilot Whale Call 1
Social calls of pilot whales as recorded by the Dtag. The image to the right shows the spectrogram (visual representation) of the call.

» Listen to Pilot Whale Call 2
Social calls of pilot whales as recorded by the Dtag. The image to the right shows the spectrogram (visual representation) of the call.

Monday, August 10, 2009

Wind and waves

Today dawned with OK weather but a forecast for increasing winds. We had positioned the ship to an area where beaked whales had been detected and weather was forecast to be best, but we did not encounter workable weather nor beaked whales. The wind increased so much that the visual team had to come down from the flying bridge in the mid-morning, and reached above 30 knots during the afternoon. The acoustic monitors could continue listening, although wave noise made it a little harder to detect signals. The rest of the teams went over data from the earlier parts of the cruise. The seas will be up, and the forecast is for continued winds, but we are hoping for enough of a window to try to tag in the next 2 days.

It must be the start of the southward migration season for european birds. We have regularly been seeing hawks from the ship. Today a hoopoe landed on the railing of a crane for awhile to rest before resuming its flight. I am afraid that the Roman augurs thought that hoopoes could detect changes in the atmosphere and that they heralded storms.... We are relying on the best meteorological data our computers deliver us, and we hope for better auguries.

Sunday, August 9, 2009

Working to tag beaked whales

Last night we set a track line for today designed to get a combination of the best weather suggested by our forecasts and the best beaked whale habitat. This morning there were low waves and whitecaps -- marginal for sighting and tracking beaked whales, but possible. We were hearing pilot and beaked whales near sunrise. We were not able to sight the beaked whales we heard, but we did sight pilot whales by 9:30. We decided to continue to try for beaked whales as they are our top priority for tagging.

The weather did not cooperate with us through most of the day, and the wind came up in the middle of the day. However, at 6 PM, the wind had changed direction and the seas lay down quickly.

The visual observers sighted beaked whales and we directed the ship to head towards the whales. Within half an hour the acoustics team picked up beaked whale clicks, probably from a different group, as the sighted whales were still making shallow dives. Right in this area, we sighted several different groups of beaked whales in a relatively short time, and hauled in the hydrophone arrays to get better mobility of the ship.

We selected a group of 3 beaked whales with no calves and with a male with a well marked dorsal fin to be the focal group we would try to tag. We prepared the tagging boat to be ready to deploy and maneuvered the ship towards the whales, which surfaced just a few hundred meters from the ship. We then slowed down the ship and were able to deploy the tag boat close to the whales, which were doing shallow dives.

For the next two hours until sunset, the weather and visibility conditions remained excellent, and the visual team used a plot of the times and locations of this group's surfacings to direct the tag boat to get as near as possible to where they thought the whales would surface. The plot comes from the GIS system that integrates all of the different kinds of data logged during the project, a real advance over earlier ways to store and display data from this kind of cruise. The key is to direct the tag boat to get within a few hundred meters of where the whales surface after a dive, so that the tag boat has time to maneuver to the whales with enough time to get close enough on a slow, quiet approach, to tag them. The tag boat did get within 20 m, but unfortunately, we ran out of daylight before we were able to tag them. The entire sequence from sighting, to acoustic detections, to maneuvering the ship and then the tag boat were as good as it gets!

It was great for the morale of the team to see how well our training has paid off. We just need more time with animals and good weather!

Saturday, August 8, 2009

A day in the work of tagging a beaked whale


The equipment and training that the teams on the Alliance have been doing are all dedicated to the difficult task of tagging beaked whales. The species we are working on in the Mediterranean Sea is Cuvier's beaked whale, Ziphius cavirostris. Today pretty much everyone on the ship was focused on this job all day.

The ideal weather for tagging a beaked whale is flat calm. Calm weather makes it easier to sight these hard-to-see animals when they surface for a series of blows lasting about 8 minutes. After a deep foraging dive that will typically last about an hour, they do a series of shallow dives each of which lasts for about 15 minutes or so. This means that the observers have to wait about an hour for their opportunity to sight whales when there is a deep foraging dive, but the duration of shallow dives is short enough that this provides the beset opportunity to tag. This means that it is critical for the research vessel to get near enough to the whales during the deep foraging dive that it can direct the tag boat near the whales during the first surfacings after shallow dives.

This morning there were light swells and light whitecaps from wind, which makes sighting beaked whales more difficult, but still possible with the excellent height of eye on this ship and with the powerful bigeye binoculars used by trained observers who know the cues that indicate a beaked whale sighting. The acoustic monitors have no problem hearing beaked whale clicks in these conditions. During the morning we detected several groups of beaked whales but they had small calves, which made them not good candidates for tagging efforts.

We continued the search throughout the day, with the teams rotating through a watch schedule to maintain high levels of attention for a difficult task. Looking for beaked whales, you need to scan the water systematically, looking for a cryptic surfacing. Unlike baleen or sperm whales, the blow is not very visible, and the beaked whale usually surfaces quickly and goes down again, meaning you have to be very attentive to see the surfacing and be able to recognize the species. Similarly for acoustics, when you are far from a beaked whale, all you will hear is a scan of several clicks as the whale’s sonar beam passes the hydrophone. This means that if the monitors take their gaze away from the computer screen for more than 10 seconds, they may miss the cue.

We continued to survey, focusing all of our efforts on detecting the beaked whales. At 5 in the afternoon, the visual team detected a group of 3-4 Ziphius at the surface with no young calf. These initial sightings are marked with a yellow triangle to the right of the figure, and are marked H and I. We left the survey line and headed towards this group. Within about 10 minutes after the whales dove, the acoustic monitors started to pick up beaked whale clicks in the direction of the group. A few minutes later as we approached closer, the acoustic monitors started hearing relatively constant series of clicks with the 0.4 sec interval between clicks that is typical of beaked whales. This meant that we were close enough to hear the clicks even when the whale was not pointing at the hydrophone. The two straight yellow lines on the plot here give acoustic bearings to the sounds of these whales at two different times. Where they intersect indicates an estimate for the location of the whales.

The ship was maneuvered to stay close enough to continue to pick up these clicks until they petered out about 20 minutes later. At this point, the ship was maneuvered to the west so that the visual observers could look away from the glare of the sun, and then was repositioned so the observers, who must orient towards the bow of the ship, had a clear view of where they expected the whales to come up. There was a strong current to the east, which caused the ship to move east. It typically takes about 20 minutes for whales to ascend to the surface after they stop clicking. The visual observers did not sight the whales for about 45 minutes after the stop of clicking, so they probably missed the first surfacing. Over this interval, the ship moved farther east than was ideal for observing the area where we expected the whales to come up. The next sighting is the one marked J1-J3 in the center of the plot, just to the left of the orange line indicating our survey track. As soon as that sighting was made, the ship could move closer and reposition.

This is the critical point to get the information required to place the tag boat near where the whales will next come up on one of their shorter dives. While one surfacing tells us where the whales are, we need a second surfacing to get an idea of their direction of travel. We prepared the tag boat for deployment, waited until the group was next sighted 19 minutes later, and deployed the tag boat 6 minutes later. For the next two hours, the visual team radioed the tag boat to position it near their estimates of where the whales would surface, then to direct it towards the whales as soon as they surfaced. Even though the tag boat was closer to the whales, the elevated platform and excellent optics of the visual team usually allowed them to sight the whales first. The whales usually only spend around 8 minutes at the surface, so the tag boat does not have long to approach the whales. We use a small quiet vessel for the tag boat and move slowly so as not to disturb the whales, so the tag boat needs to be within a few hundred meters of the whales when they surface in order to have a chance to tag.

One complication with our tagging attempt today, was that the whales, which had been moving consistently WSW the entire time until the sightings marked J13-J14, suddenly switched direction, surfacing to the E in surfacings J16 and J17, then off to the NE for the final two surfacings. While the tag boat could see the whales, they did not get close enough for any opportunities to tag before sunset and we recovered the tag boat a little after 9 PM.

The equipment and teams are intensely focused on tagging and are operating at a high level. Even so, beaked whales are so difficult, that our previous experience suggests that it will take days of these efforts to succeed in tagging a whale. We just need to keep doing what I have described here.