Saturday, August 22, 2009

Ditto

Today was a repeat of yesterday -- if anything a little worse. We had steady 15 knot winds for most of the day picking up to near 20 later on. We surveyed for pilot whales until afternoon when it became too strong to search for anything visually. As yesterday, we continue to search acoustically and some beaked whale clicks were detected during the day in areas where we had sighted them before. So they are still where we expect them to be and we can detect them using our acoustic assets, but even being right on top of them it is impossible to spot them visually in the Beaufort 5 wind conditions.

The Beaufort scale is an empirical measurement of wind speed that is related to sea conditions. To give you a sense of how remarkably calm we need the conditions to be, consider that the scale goes from 0-12 and 5 (our wind for much of today) is categorized as a "fresh breeze" of 15-20 knots (29-38 km/hr or 16-24 mph) and the resulting seas have moderate waves of some length, many white caps, and small amounts of spray. For sighting and tagging beaked whales, we need Beaufort 0 ("clam" with winds <1 knots), Beaufort 1 ("light air" with winds 1-2 knots), or Beaufort 2 ("light breeze" of 3-6 knots) conditions. Anything Beaufort 3, a "gentle breeze" of 7-10 knots (12-19 km/hr, 8-12 mph), or above makes it difficult or impossible to visually detect and tag beaked whales. Beaufort 3 and 4 ("moderate breeze" of 11-15 knots) can be workable with pilot whales and other cetaceans, but at Beaufort 5 we tend to put the covers on the big-eye binoculars, not because we can't take it but because it isn't worth looking.

We continue to refine and cross-calibrate all our detection systems and await the opportunity. Tomorrow looks as bad in terms of wind and the seas may be building with the steady wind from the east, though we have learned not to put too much faith in weather forecasts. We are moving to what we hope may be a better area in terms of weather where beaked whales have been spotted previously.

Friday, August 21, 2009

Blown Out

Despite the favorable predictions, the weather front we expected tomorrow seemed to arrive a day early. We experienced winds around 15 knots for most of the day with regular whitecaps - conditions that are inconsistent with spotting beaked whales visually. We continued in survey mode focusing on areas where we might expect pilot whales; the weather would have allowed us to work with them for most of the day. While we were waiting for conditions to improve, we made measurements comparing how our different acoustic systems performed in detecting the same underwater sounds in order to further refine capabilities and procedures. We also made additional oceanographic measurements and conducted acoustic surveys in support of the habitat modeling efforts that will benefit from MED -09 data.

Thursday, August 20, 2009

Many Beaked Whales (most with calves)

We had another very good day today in terms of wind and sea conditions. We consequently found many cetaceans, including our primary species of interest. We worked mostly in the deep axis of the same canyon area and detected many groups of Cuvier's beaked whales throughout a very long and full day of activity. Acoustic surveys begin at 0500, visuals come on at dawn, and both teams operated continuously throughout the day with these many animals. As you can see from the picture here, it was another pleasant sunset but we just missed getting a tag on at the very end of the day.

Around 20 different groups of beaked whales were sighted, in addition to a large number of the four other species we've been seeing regularly out here (pilot whales, and common, striped, and Risso's dolphins). While it is likely some of these were the same groups at different points in the day, or different combinations of groups (they do come together and break off from one another), with the distance we traveled it is likely we detected a dozen or so distinct individuals or groups. This confirms earlier evidence that this is an excellent place to find these elusive animals when the conditions are right and we have the capabilities that exist on this ship. However, despite the large number of sightings, it took many hours to find a good candidate group, as almost all those we found today (as yesterday) had one or more calves or were single individuals. In the late afternoon we found a good group of adult and sub-adult animals that we tracked for about four hours, both visually and acoustically through relatively shallow surface intervals and one deep foraging dive (after which we found them at the surface again). We vectored the tag boat during the subsequent surface intervals and we again came tantalizingly close (within a few feet) of tagging the animals before they slipped into the depths again.

We expect good conditions again tomorrow and will give it our all again. We will be trying some similar areas where we hope to be less likely to find so many groups with calves that we cannot work around. Despite it impacting our ability to work many of the groups here, the large number of calves is encouraging and we are learning some interesting things about the ecology and behavior of these poorly known animals in when and where we find groups with different social structure. It is remarkable how challenging these animals are to work with, even with the amazing amount of expertise and technology available to us, but we know this can be done and we should have another good chance tomorrow if the forecast holds true.

Wednesday, August 19, 2009

Calmer Seas -- Many Animals

Today dawned calmer with light seas and winds between just 5-10 knots for most of the day dropping to almost zero by late afternoon and evening. These are the conditions we need to reliably sight and tag beaked whales. Throughout the day we sighted many cetaceans, including hundreds of common, striped, and Risso's dolphins, pilot whales, and about 8-10 different groups of Cuvier's beaked whales. Both teams monitored the vast horizon and the cacophonous underwater acoustic scene these animals covered, trying to find the right situation. Several times our acoustic teams were hampered in extracting the beaked whale clicks from similar vocalizations from other nearby species. Also, almost all of the groups of beaked whales we found today either had small calves or were single individuals, which meant we could not work with them for different reasons. We did follow two different (we think!) groups of adult animals near the end of the day as good candidates, but despite the flat seas, visuals, acoustics, and tag boat in the water, they gave us the slip.

The figure you see here shows a bit of our track from today and gives you a sense of the relative movement of the animals and some of our tactics in using different sensing gear in monitoring their movement and behavior. The orange line shows the movement of the vessel starting at the southern edge of the plot (note the depth contours in meters along the track). The crosses with numbers 1-10 show different positions of a real-time, high-frequency GPS sonobuoy we dropped early in this encounter. These locations are over about four hours and if you noted the sonobuoy tracks from the blog several days ago you can appreciate the quite different current conditions we encountered today. The red triangles are sequential positions and headings of the focal group of beaked whales we were tracking. The triangles of other colors are sightings of other cetacean species and the little boat symbol is the position of our inflatable tag boat. As you can see, the animals increasingly tracked to the north and then the northeast (away from our first sonobuoy) and we monitored them from some distance, relying entirely on the visual team to track them since they are silent during the surface diving interval. When the group went for a deep (~1000m or more) dive after the last red triangles, we dropped our towed arrays back in the water and initiated a large circle around their position to monitor for their clicks. You can see some orange symbols along the Alliance track during this circle, showing that we successfully detected the animals with expected bearings during this period. This plot shows the complexity and integration of the visual and acoustic capabilities we have here, how they complement one another to enable us to monitor deep-diving animals in real-time, and the importance of real-time GIS visualization to guide our decision making in this challenging task.

The forecast for tomorrow and Friday is for excellent conditions such as we had today followed by possibly high winds over the weekend so we are all very much focused on the window the next few days looks to hopefully afford us.

Tuesday, August 18, 2009

Unscheduled Stop -- Bumpy Seas

Last night we ran an all-night passive acoustic survey on our way back toward the Spanish coast through the dark. We needed to make a brief, unplanned return to enable some medical assessments and crew-changes. Safety comes first and everyone is well and on the ship ready for action. Nevertheless, it took much of the day away from our efforts to tag beaked whales, though we did return into deep water in search of them by late afternoon. However, our return to what we believe (based on previous observations) to be good beaked whale habitat largely confirmed the earlier weather forecasts of conditions that would be unsuitable for sighting and tagging beaked whales; none were sighted or heard on the acoustic systems today.


Multiple dolphin groups were sighted, and at one point several large groups of dozens of common dolphins were swimming and socializing on all sides of our vessel. We weren't traveling fast enough for them to want to ride on the bow wave, but they streaked gracefully around and by us for 20 minutes. A group of Risso's dolphins was sighted just after dinner, but by about 2000 the wind and swell were at unworkable levels. Tomorrow we plan to work through a deep canyon where many previous sightings of beaked whales have been made. The forecast is for marginal conditions much of the day but calming in the area where we will be operating in the afternoon.

Monday, August 17, 2009

Beaked Whales Near Sunset

Our first full day on effort for the second leg dawned windier than hoped. Seas were light, but the 10-15 knot winds made things difficult for the visual teams who came on at first light. Acoustics had a large amount of dolphin activity again before dawn but did not pick up any beaked whales while scanning. We ran a slightly westerly track across promising areas for deep-diving whales in order to keep the glare from the rising sun from making things harder for the visual team. Despite our efforts, there was little action through the morning and mid-day other than some scattered groups of dolphins and our regular oceanographic and ambient noise measurements.

As has been the case for much of the project, however, the weather began to cooperate in the late afternoon and early evening. We came back through some canyon-like areas where beaked whales had been detected previously and found five different groups as the seas began to settle, in addition to several groups of common and Risso's dolphins. Here you can see a Cuvier's beaked whale "spyhopping" to have a look above the surface. Unfortunately we had several groups that were not good candidates for tagging attempts because of their group composition or how they were traveling. The two groups we attempted to tag stayed too far from the tag boats for us to attach acoustic tags before the setting sun ended our efforts for today.

The outlook for tomorrow is for even stronger winds (up to 20 knots) and moderate swell, which will prove very challenging if the forecast is correct. We continue our passive acoustic surveys at all possible times and will conduct these throughout the night tonight.

Sunday, August 16, 2009

Drills, Waves, and By-catch

Today was the first operational day of the second leg of MED -09. Some gear had been adjusted or repaired and new personnel were in certain key roles, so we began the day deploying and testing the hardware and software needed for the very challenging task of finding, following, tagging, and safely exposing beaked whales to sound. We remained vigilant throughout these drills for animals either seen or heard (and we did have some -- see below), but the weather was marginal with winds around 10-15 knots for most of the day and a light swell. So we did not feel we were missing perfect conditions in working through the drills deliberately, and with so many things that must go right here to succeed we require considerable precision in the sequence and timing of deployments.

After a successful test of one of the repaired passive listening systems that had been having some problems, we conducted a drill of deploying an array of real-time listening buoys (called "sonobuoys") we will use to monitor vocalizing whales once a focal group is tagged. One of our small boats delivered the sonobuoys in a grid while we deployed the sound source for controlled exposure experiments to a depth of 75 m (but did not turn it on). Meanwhile, our visual team practiced tracking a "whale" (which was actually our own tagging boat) and we tested our ability to safely maneuver for visual monitoring with both the listening gear and the source in the water. As you can see from the plot here, we dropped a total of four sonobuoys (labelled A-D) in a counter-clockwise fashion at a spacing of about 2.5 km. These listening devices have a relatively deep listening sensor and relay sound information using a radio signal back to the ship; with them we can monitor the area around focal whale groups during a controlled sound exposure. This figure shows one of the challenges we face here in the dynamic Alboran Sea, which is the affect of currents on free-floating buoys. Notice that various green symbols (starting from the north) moved consistently to the SSE over time (on average about 4.5 km in 2.5 hours). For instance, note the four green bulls-eye symbols furthest to the east labeled "Sonobuoy B" and the consistent drift (time noted for just this example). We know from the ship's sensors that there was a fairly strong current (almost 2 knots) in this direction, so this was not surprising to us. However, it demonstrates another challenge facing us in being able to not only read the position and behavior of the animals, but also the position and behavior of our monitoring gear in relation to the movement of the water (and other factors such as the wind and sun). Practice and drills are required to understand and manage such challenges, which was part of why we worked so carefully through it today. Ultimately we were very pleased with the timing of the operation and in our ability to monitor an area in which we and all our gear was being strongly moved in the active sea.

We continued to monitor acoustically and visually for marine mammals and did manage a number of detections in both modalities of several species. Some Cuvier's beaked whales were heard early in the day but not seen and then a total of five animals were sighted near sunset. Additional detections were made of other cetaceans, including Risso's dolphins, striped dolphins, and common dolphins, although no attempt was made to tag these animals.

Unfortunately, one of the common dolphins we located had been caught in a fishing net and was floating dead in the water. As you can see from the picture here, it had been killed relatively recently and the flukes (tail) and dorsal fin were severed, presumably by fishermen trying to remove the entangled animal without cutting their nets. We approached the carcass in one of the small boats to document the species (Delphinus delphis) and sex (female) and to obtain photo documentation and samples for genetic analysis. We also sighted an ocean sunfish floating dead and seemingly entangled and what may have also been a dead sea turtle as well. By-catch (the incidental killing of animals in fishing gear) is a serious problem for marine mammals around the world, including here in the western Mediterranean.

We hope for better weather and less morbid observations tomorrow and are primed and ready to accomplish our objectives if weather and animals will allow. Knock on wood, the forecast looks more promising.